◆ Rare · Butters

Cookie Butter

Fresh Batch squishy

Rarity

Rare

Style

Fresh Batch

Shape

Butters

How to get it

Pull-only

Released

2026-08-03

Baked, chipped, and cracked across the top the way a cookie does when it spreads too fast. Warm out of the oven and never quite cooled since, which is the part nobody at the dairy will address directly.

Pull-only. It comes from pulls in the app, where the odds for every squishy are shown.